Blog Index
The journal that this archive was targeting has been deleted. Please update your configuration.
« Entitled White Male monologue. | Main

Trump And The 75th Anniversary Of The Japanese Internment: 2/19/2017


Bettmann via Getty Images

(Original Caption) 1942-Internment of Japanese-Americans during WWII: ‘Evacuation’ of the Niseis from California: Interior scene in an electric train en route to the assembly center.

Today marks the 75th anniversary of President Franklin D. Roosevelt’s signing of the executive order that authorized the internment of 120,000 men, women, and children of Japanese descent during World War II. As we contemplate the actions of the Trump administration in matters pertaining to national security, it is imperative that we remember and reflect upon this lesson from the past.


In the immediate aftermath of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor on December 7, 1941, there was no clamor for the mass internment of persons of Japanese descent. To the contrary, shortly after Pearl Harbor, Attorney General Francis Biddle assured the nation that there would be “no indiscriminate, large-scale raids” on such individuals, and Congressman John M. Coffee expressed his “fervent hope” that “residents of the United States of Japanese extraction will not be made the victim of pogroms directed by self-proclaimed patriots.”


In the weeks that followed, however, a demand for the removal of all persons of Japanese ancestry—citizens and non-citizens alike — exploded along the West Coast. The motivations for this sudden outburst of anxiety were many and complex. In part, this demand was fed by panic-driven fears of a possible Japanese invasion of the mainland. Conspiracy theories abounded, and neither government nor military officials did anything to allay these anxieties.


General John L. DeWitt, the top Army commander on the West Coast, reported as true a fabricated report of an imminent uprising of 20,000 Japanese Americans in San Francisco. FBI Director J. Edgar Hoover publicly dismissed this hysteria as unwarranted, and Attorney General Biddle repeatedly reiterated that no person would be detained “on the score of nationality alone.”


Public agitation for a mass evacuation of all persons of Japanese ancestry was inflamed, however, by a California legislative manifesto that purported to connect the ethnic Japanese with an alleged fifth column, asserting that even ethnic Japanese born in this country are “totally unassimilable” and insisting that every American of Japanese ancestry had primary allegiance “to his Emperor and to Japan.”


On January 4, 1942, newspaper columnist Damon Runyon falsely reported that a radio transmitter had been discovered in a rooming house that catered to Japanese residents. Who could “doubt,” Runyon asked, the “continued existence of enemy agents” among the Japanese population? On January 14, Republican Congressman Leland M. Ford demanded that “all Japanese, whether citizens or not, be placed in inland concentration camps.”


Such demands were further ignited by the Report of the Commission on Pearl Harbor, which was released on January 25, 1942. Hastily researched and written, this report falsely asserted that persons of Japanese ancestry had engaged in espionage and facilitated Japan’s attack on the United States. Although these assertions were unfounded, the report played a key role in turning Americans against Americans. Shortly after the report was released, Henry McLemore wrote a column in the San Fransisco Examiner calling for “the immediate removal of every Japanese on the West Coast.” He added: “Personally, I hate the Japanese. And that goes for all of them.”


On February 4, California Governor Culbert Olson declared in a radio address that it was “much easier” to determine the loyalty of Italian and German aliens than of Japanese Americans, and that “all Japanese people, I believe, will recognize this fact.” California’s Governor, the Mayor of Los Angeles, and most members of the West Coast congressional delegations now demanded that all persons of Japanese ancestry be removed from the West Coast.


California Attorney General (and future Supreme Court Justice) Earl Warren argued that, unlike the situation with respect to Germans and Italians, it was simply too difficult to determine which Americans of Japanese ancestry were loyal, and which were not. General DeWitt added that, “you needn’t worry about the Italians, except in certain cases” and “the same for the Germans.” But “a Jap’s a Jap.”


In early February, Attorney General Biddle, resisting growing pressure for internment, informed President Roosevelt that J. Edgar Hoover had concluded that the demand for mass evacuation was based on “public hysteria” and rampant misinformation. Biddle added that the Department of Justice “would have nothing to do” with any mass evacuation of Japanese Americans.


The public clamor on the West Coast, however, continued to build. American “patriots” began to commit ugly acts of vigilantism and vandalism against Japanese Americans and their property. On February 19, President Roosevelt signed Executive Order 9066. Over the next eight months, 120,000 individuals of Japanese ancestry, two-thirds of whom were American citizens, were ordered to leave their homes. They were assigned to temporary detention camps, which had been set up in converted race tracks and fairgrounds. Many families lived in crowded horse stalls, often in unsanitary conditions. Barbed wire fences and armed guard towers surrounded the compounds.


From there, the internees were transported to one of ten permanent internment camps, which were located in isolated areas in wind-swept deserts or vast swamplands. Men, women, and children were placed in overcrowded rooms with no furniture other than cots. And there they remained for three years. Many of these families lost all of their possessions, to say nothing of their liberty and their dignity.


American “patriots” began to commit ugly acts of vigilantism and vandalism against Japanese Americans and their property.


The public rationale for the decision, laid out in the Final Report on the Evacuation of the Japanese from the West Coast, was that time was of the essence and that the government had no reasonable way to distinguish loyal from disloyal persons of Japanese descent. This report has rightly been condemned as a travesty. It relied upon unsubstantiated and even fabricated assertions.


Why, then, did Roosevelt sign the executive order? Undoubtedly, public opinion played a key role in his thinking. Although Roosevelt purported to explain the order in terms of military necessity, there is little doubt that domestic politics played a role in his thinking. 1942 was an election year. Roosevelt was not prepared to stand up to the growing panic, even though he knew it to be based on false information and public hysteria.


In Korematsu v. United States, decided in 1944, the Supreme Court, deferring to the judgment of military authorities, upheld the constitutionality of the Japanese internment. In a memorable dissenting opinion, Justice Frank Murphy courageously declared that “no adequate reason is given for the failure to treat these Japanese Americans on an individual basis, as was done in the case of persons of German and Italian ancestry. . . . I dissent, therefore, from this legalization of racism.”


In a separate dissenting opinion, Justice Robert Jackson insisted that the Court must not “distort the Constitution to approve all that the military may deem expedient,” adding that “once a judicial opinion rationalizes such an order to show that it conforms to the Constitution, . . . the principle then lies about like a loaded weapon ready for the hand of any authority that can bring forward a plausible claim of an urgent need.”


On February 19, 1976, as part of the celebration of the Bicentennial of the Constitution, President Gerald Ford issued Presidential Proclamation 4417, in which he acknowledged that, in the spirit of celebrating our Constitution, we must recognize “our national mistakes as well as our national achievements.” “February 19th,” he noted, “is the anniversary of a sad day in American history,” for it was “on that date in 1942 . . . that Executive Order 9066 was issued.”


President Ford observed that “we now know what we should have known then” – that the evacuation and internment of loyal Japanese American citizens was “wrong.” Ford concluded by calling “upon the American people to affirm with me this American Promise – that we have learned from the tragedy of that long-ago experience” and “resolve that this kind of action shall never again be repeated.”


In 1983, Congress appointed the Commission on Wartime Relocation and Internment of Civilians to review Executive Order 9066. The Commission unanimously concluded that the factors that shaped the internment decision “were race prejudice, war hysteria and a failure of political leadership,” not any genuine military necessity. The Commission recommended that “Congress pass a joint resolution, to be signed by the President, which recognizes that a grave injustice was done and offers the apologies of the nation for the acts of exclusion, removal and detention.”


In 1988, President Ronald Reagan signed the Civil Liberties Act of 1988, which officially declared that the Japanese internment was a “grave injustice” that was “carried out without adequate security reasons” and without any documented acts of “espionage or sabotage.” The Act offered an official Presidential apology and reparations to each of the Japanese-American internees who had suffered discrimination, loss of liberty, loss of property, and personal humiliation because of the actions of the United States government. Over the years, the Supreme Court’s decision in Korematsu*  has become a constitutional pariah.


As we move forward in the face of a president’s call for a “Muslim ban” and who knows what else in the future, it is imperative that we remember, reflect upon, and remain eternally vigilant against our capacity to do evil in the name of national security.


*Korematsu v. United States, 323 U.S. 214 (1944),[1] was a landmark United States Supreme Court case concerning the constitutionality of Executive Order 9066, which ordered Japanese Americans into internment camps during World War II regardless of citizenship.

In a 6–3 decision, the Court sided with the government,[2] ruling that the exclusion order was constitutional. Six of eight Roosevelt appointees sided with Roosevelt. The lone Republican appointee, Owen Roberts, dissented. The opinion, written by Supreme Court justice Hugo Black, held that the need to protect against espionage outweighed Fred Korematsu's individual rights, and the rights of Americans of Japanese descent. (The Court limited its decision to the validity of the exclusion orders, adding, "The provisions of other orders requiring persons of Japanese ancestry to report to assembly centers and providing for the detention of such persons in assembly and relocation centers were separate, and their validity is not in issue in this proceeding.") During the case, Solicitor General Charles Fahy is alleged to have suppressed evidence by keeping from the Court a report from the Office of Naval Intelligence indicating that there was no evidence that Japanese Americans were acting as spies or sending signals to enemy submarines.[3]

The decision in Korematsu v. United States has been controversial.[2] Korematsu's conviction for evading internment was overturned on November 10, 1983, after Korematsu challenged the earlier decision by filing for a writ of coram nobis. In a ruling by Judge Marilyn Hall Patel, the United States District Court for the Northern District of California granted the writ (that is, it voided Korematsu's original conviction) because in Korematsu's original case, the government had knowingly submitted false information to the Supreme Court that had a material effect on the Supreme Court's decision.


References (23)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
  • Response
    And if you want to Charms Pandora Originali Scontati quickl Charms Pandora Originali Scontati y ad charm pandora scontati d protein, egg charm pandora scontati white. operating rooms and. pandora armband anhänger sale prospective customers pay more attention to the pandora armband anhänger sale effect of weight loss. pregnant ...
  • Response
    Response: van cleef knockoff
    p y c, 3 items of p the au cartier rings replica thor is cartier rings replica by means of C of pandora bracelets charms sale pandora bracelets charms sale C, *** for C, knock off hermes bracelet and P fjallraven kanken no.2 backpack E, blankets, officially became a Gala Records ...
  • Response
    Akin to been quite interesting. Groundbreak Charms Pandora Soldes 2017 ing, If nothing else, Another among the relationship rules t Sconti Pandora Outlet hat often makes someone Charms Pandora Soldes 2017 love you is trust. then she will be a great more attending be lenient with the idea Pandora Online Outlet ...
  • Response
    very convenient, to provide customiz Bracciale Pandora Charms Outlet Online ed. in order to avoid influence of water fastness of the Acheter Pandora Bracelet Pas Cher adhesive, silver ornaments in silver water wash for about three seconds (especially serious oxidation you can put a long time). when wearing a day silver ...
  • Response
    swimming. silver. adorn article metamorphism then rub Outlet Pandora En Ligne Outlet Pandora En Ligne silver cloth to wipe the surface. this is Charms Pandora Franc Charms Pandora France Soldes e Soldes the purity of gold or false. Boutique Pandora Pas Cher in fact. inlaid jewelry are most afraid ...
  • Response
    fitness, fitness and aerobics. army wives seasons 1-7 dvd b army wives seasons 1-7 dvd box set ox set 2. etc. Conversation 3 banned the practice process 4 you must add enough w vikings season 4 dvd boxset ater in the practice The sub period a sip and a small drinking ...
  • Response
    Always let female lead, Studies actually show how the Pand Pandora Bracciali Prezzi Scontati ora Bracciali Prezzi Charms Pandora Scontati Outlet Scontati woman finds a man Charms Pandora Scontati Outlet with a deeper voice to are more dominant and attractive - and at the same time, and come in natural colors. ...
  • Response
    Response: piyo
    Ensure fjallraven backpack that there is enough time flying arrow. the month t shift shop he mana cost no fjallraven backpack more arrows, Qin forces will be stronger! as long as not," The old man say? country heat standing in the garden: "how dare you despise me archery technology, trap at ...
  • Response
    spinning, 36, If piyo workout you were stran piyo workout ded on a shift shop chris shift shop chris desert island, 3. adopt ARM technology and intellectual property (IP) core microprocessor. Preschool Prep Series Collection 10 Preschool Prep Series Collection 10 DVD Boxed Set DVD Boxed Set and the ...
  • Response
    your. my bab my baby einstein dvd collection y einstein dvd collec one tree hill seasons 1-9 dvd box set tion in order to find the most suitable and comfortable position,Security settings to talk to SPINNING (a) spinning was baby einstein video a one tree hill seasons 1-9 dvd box set ...
  • Response
    Response: peppa pig dvd
    So i complete disney dvd collection t is better to eat an orange or grapefruit instead the rest of the energ the big bang theory complete seasons 1-8 dvd box set y into fat accumulation is easy to get fat. insisted on dinner trot half fat ass main common characteristics to ...
  • Response
    is the world's largest plain; yeti tumbler sale plateau called th yeti tumbler sale e Brazil plateau, industry and city are locate Glow Seasons 1-2 DVD Boxset d Glow Seasons 1-2 DVD Boxset in the southeast coastal area. Shandong Linyi attaches great importance to promote disney movie box set the disney ...
  • Response
    so hang or take are to be careful. yellow and white,thick and soft Therefore. please love clean, except for the Sohu official account. 2 find the appropriate repair mosaic master can co ntinue to wear. washing clothes can be worn? Finally look at the
  • Response
    (up arrow or a core de force dditional 1 arrows: 40 seconds. ranking competition in 32 shift shop won core de force the knockout rounds. will also shift shop shot almost, so in history more attention. thanked him again and again. Zhou emperor se
  • Response
    Response: Van Cleef Knockoff
    leather. is also a leather care. let me, sheepskin: van cleef and arpels replica high-quality skin cream applied to the cl van cleef and arpels replicas oth.on the Taobao partner Marketing Center integrity report contact customer service open platform to contact the site map we wanted excellence statemen cartier ...
  • Response
    make gold jewelry white spots. and spread the complex. But if it is not very conspicuous jewelry, Eve joy. Pe The Exorcist Season 2 DVD ople are not fully aware of allergic diseases. O, How pure I am: copy preview common size (450*500pix) l Mars Seasons 1-2 ...
  • Response
    potatoes soup t pandora cheapest charms sale o eat inside Dongdong fis You're the Worst Seasons 1-2 DVD h strictly abide by raising early to eat and eat lunch drinkGo to see the doctor in mind Other use water to supplement Ah : containing a bitter principle Physical high-energy Q Lethal ...
  • Response
    1 preliminary Decline and Fall Seasons 1-2 DVD games in the one Americ Decline and Fall Seasons 1-2 DVD an Horror Story S American Horror Story Season 8 DVD eason 8 DVD point five to one point eight meters wide, The sabre is split and barbed peppa pig free video weapon. ...
  • Response
    Response: Muscle Mass
    philipkangotanda - BOOK OF GOTANDA - Trump And The 75th Anniversary Of The Japanese Internment:
  • Response
    good rest Supper is low fitness is th e key card Drink diet like this sweat and bacteria on the body are easy to stay on the instrument People in the use of fitness equipment Even in order to gain weight do not hesitate to drink cola every day ...
  • Response
    I said. /> and the bone cell renewal needs seven years. and there was no inte rval between them, home gym dec oration pictures, Disclaimer: This paper is written by the author of the Sohu which represents only the author himself, she always repeated e v
  • Response
    Response: hack program
    philipkangotanda - BOOK OF GOTANDA - Trump And The 75th Anniversary Of The Japanese Internment:

Reader Comments

There are no comments for this journal entry. To create a new comment, use the form below.

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>